Should Carytown be pedestrian only?

Readers chimed in on the popular Richmond question

RICtoday_CarFree_Carytown_AI

The Rainbow Road would be a bonus.

Rendering by @betterstreetsai

On Monday, we floated the idea of a car-free Carytown in the newsletter and on Instagram. Here’s what readers had to say about the popular proposal.

A lot of people suggested a pedestrian-only schedule — and pointed to other cities with car-free streets.

“Absolutely! Install retractable pylons that can be lowered to allow traffic on some schedule and raised to create a pedestrian mall on schedule.” – @riversideoutfittersrva

“Yes, on weekends at least. Works great at old town Alexandria off king st” – @seefitz

“If the city could build some parking structures, convert ellwood 2 way to Arthur Ashe (which would slow down cars), then convert Cary from Thompson-Arthur Ashe to pedestrian mall like Charlottesville’s, that would be the most ideal!!!!” – @emilyroutman

Parking was a common concern.

“Sounds great if they had extra parking decks built - it’s already hard to find parking now.” – @missyrothrock

“YES! But realistically there would have to be more parking garages. Underground ones would be awesome to not block the beautiful surroundings!” – Reader Elizabeth H.

“Yes and no. It would become more of a popular place for sure, and revenues for business would profit. But where will everyone park? Maybe a couple of parking decks?” – @nicktheheartist

“That would be so dope but certainly want to listen to and find solutions for concerns of our disabled neighbors [...] and a plan for the overflow parking and traffic. But yeahhhhh!” – @nerdcropolis

Readers also shared other development dreams.

“In addition to Carytown, I’d like to see segments of Floyd, Cherry, and Shafer around VCU be transformed into car-free zones — note that this is different than pedestrian-only zones. These areas would need designated bike lanes and Carytown would need a bus-only lane.” – Reader Angela L.

“[...] Continuing to bolster the city’s bike lanes would be helpful too. A north/south Pulse line sounds like a good idea.” – Reader Kyle S.

We love forecasting the future of the River City. Feel free to keep chiming in on social media or in our inbox.

More from RICtoday
RICtoday has been nominated in Style Weekly’s annual Best of Richmond poll, and you can cast your votes now through the end of March.
Put your money where your community is and help us create a guide to small businesses by submitting your favorite local spots and sharing this page with a friend.
Crunch the numbers with us, and see what areas of improvement the city noted following Richmond’s double-header winter storms.
Help beautify your neighborhood, and become part of a nationwide habit network.
Eager to get on the road, but don’t want to travel too far? Try these nearby destinations for day trips, plus see our bonus recommendations for weekend stays.
Make the most of good weather by taking your meals al fresco on one of Richmond’s many beautiful patios.
“My Faire Lady” debuts this weekend. Learn about the beer, the party, and the inspiration behind the beer’s hand-painted symbol.
Needlepoint is one of the hottest “anolog” hobbies right now. Find our where to find supplies and meet other stitchers.
Bookmark this page to your favorites tab so you can quickly return and find the top events happening each month in Richmond.
We found three online surveys to help you share feedback on budgeting, parks, and public safety.