There are two places to get a fresh, local bagel within city limits: Nate’s and Chewy’s. We can’t pick a favorite — and you don’t have to.
For this celebration of all things River City bagels, we’re boiling down the two spots based on reader recommendations and each of their specific strengths.
Graphic by RICtoday
🥯 Nate’s Bagels , 21 S. Allen Ave.
Strengths: Sandwich options, take-away service, open earlier
If you want a hearty bagel, Nate’s has a ton of signature sandwiches. Particularly if there are carnivores in your crew, the Fan spot has more protein options. They’ve also got a streamlined order ahead system in addition to in-person service.
Editor’s Pick: The Breakfast Banh Mi on a whole wheat bagel is a must-try.
Graphic by RICtoday
🥯 Chewy’s Bagels , 3138 W. Cary St.
Strengths: Toasting, delivery around town, cream cheese display
Chewy’s toasts its bagels — and for some, that’s a deal-breaker. You can also find them around Richmond, at local grocery stores + select cafes . Plus, the shop’s homemade spreads are quite tempting.
Editor’s Pick: Start the day with the Garden Veggie sandwich on an everything bagel.
Readers shouted out both spots for their schmear selection, and several praised third-party candidate Cupertino’s , located in Henrico County.
When it comes to a winner in our bagel battle, we have to agree with Reader Michelle U., who wrote: “Geez, why don’t you just ask me to choose my favorite child!”